Well as the title says, is the Emotional Atyachaar really good ? If you've watched it then please say how you liked it ?
Anyone watched Dev D ?
I went to watch it today and I gotta say its one of the best hindi movies i've ever seen. Even though I don't watch many, but my choice is restricted to the most popular ones, and this movie just topped them!
This one has got some really rave reviews. Would watch it soon.
Hmmm... I am going for it... reviews are praising it
Times of India gave it a 5/5
CNN IBN 2/5
contrasting reviews...
CNN IBN 2/5
contrasting reviews...
So it is not really atyachaar on us??
I'VE NOT YET WATCHED THE MOVIE
I think if u are used to the type of movies Anurag Kashyap kakes, u'd love it.
I liked "No Smoking" and I shouldn't talk about "Black Friday"....
I guess he can be called our "Kubrick"...
I think if u are used to the type of movies Anurag Kashyap kakes, u'd love it.
I liked "No Smoking" and I shouldn't talk about "Black Friday"....
I guess he can be called our "Kubrick"...
A
its psychedelic man...you gotta be high to watch this movie...it blew my mind away...
more of a Darren Aronofsky than Kubrick i'll say!
by the way, i've not seen original Devdas . Will it be any problem ?
by the way, i've not seen original Devdas . Will it be any problem ?
^^+1 I too haven't seen the original.
By Psychedelic I hope it seems better than Dark Knight when it comes to MAINSTREAM psycological thrillers.
By Psychedelic I hope it seems better than Dark Knight when it comes to MAINSTREAM psycological thrillers.
Alright, then I'm most knowledgeable on Devdas...
I've read the original Bengali novel
Old Bengali movie acted by Uttamkumar (I don't know anyone heard about him els bengalis)
Old Dileep kumar version
and
Shahrukh version
Its not a thriller (if I understood u correctly)...its love...lose...separation...self destruction...etc.
And, psychedelic in this movie...I think is the abstract presentation of the character's mind...Anurag Kashyap is best in it...
I've read the original Bengali novel
Old Bengali movie acted by Uttamkumar (I don't know anyone heard about him els bengalis
)Old Dileep kumar version
and
Shahrukh version
Its not a thriller (if I understood u correctly)...its love...lose...separation...self destruction...etc.
And, psychedelic in this movie...I think is the abstract presentation of the character's mind...Anurag Kashyap is best in it...
^^kindly see Dev.D jaldi se.......and tell us if non Devdas viewer will miss anything
Thats the exact way I see dark knight. Behind the thriller is an AWESOME character contrast, involving THREE people, Batman, Harvy and Joker.
Anyway, the way you describe it, it looks like something to see. Lemme look out for it.
Its probably going to be one of those cult movies. Something like Mithya, but better. I love these movies, they are refreshingly good unlike the mainstream movies.
Hope its not like No Smoking..That one totally went over my head
Alright folks, coming from Dev.D...
7.5 to 8 in 10 is my rating.
I expected it to be more abstract but Anurag Kashyap has toned down his art of abstract story telling from "No Smoking" level, I think everyone needs to think about business. BUT its still out there which none can touch...
The movie needs a bit editing to be more sharp and smart...
The Paro part of the movie is a bit slow at times and Mahie Gill was weak some places.
I mostly loved the Chanda (kalki Koechlin) and Dev part of the movie, the Chanda girl is brilliant. She definitely knows what she is doing.
Those who have not watched Devdas would like the movie but you have to keep ur mind open, its more like binary...either u'll like or dislike the movie...no mix reaction can be evoked seeing it.
Those who have watched and LIKED/LOVED the old Devdas, they would miss the Pain, suffocation and helplessness in this movie a bit. Dev.D is not emo movie like its ancestors, its more like in-ur-face movie; in this time no one has time to stop and repent for years and die of self-pity...u get a replacement, either u want it or u don't. It happens.
While in hall I didn't quite like it, but I think I like it now.
7.5 to 8 in 10 is my rating.
I expected it to be more abstract but Anurag Kashyap has toned down his art of abstract story telling from "No Smoking" level, I think everyone needs to think about business. BUT its still out there which none can touch...
The movie needs a bit editing to be more sharp and smart...
The Paro part of the movie is a bit slow at times and Mahie Gill was weak some places.
I mostly loved the Chanda (kalki Koechlin) and Dev part of the movie, the Chanda girl is brilliant. She definitely knows what she is doing.
Those who have not watched Devdas would like the movie but you have to keep ur mind open, its more like binary...either u'll like or dislike the movie...no mix reaction can be evoked seeing it.
Those who have watched and LIKED/LOVED the old Devdas, they would miss the Pain, suffocation and helplessness in this movie a bit. Dev.D is not emo movie like its ancestors, its more like in-ur-face movie; in this time no one has time to stop and repent for years and die of self-pity...u get a replacement, either u want it or u don't. It happens.
While in hall I didn't quite like it, but I think I like it now.
Then plz. don't watch it.
a sign of great movie!!!!!the one that grows on you!!
I liked the movie was pretty fun. Kept you engrossed, we didn't realize that the movie was so long.
Hmmm...looks like I mat watch it!
Now I am more eager than ever to watch this movie !
high hona padega ? kya sutta + beer kaam karega
jokes apart, I like offbeat mind fcking movies like A CLOCKWORK ORANGE etc
so NO SMOKING was good for me ...atleast songs lyrics were kewl..phhooonk de ..jab bhi cigarette jalti hai ...
so gotta watch DEV D inspite of any review
trainspotting ?
4/5
7\10,a 5\10 if the music wasn't so epic.
Anurag kashyap has tried to slow down the movie for the mainstream public,and he kind of failed.he should stop doing it,if they can't understand it,let it be.Abhay deol is great,atleast one of the deols know how to act.Mahie gill was mediocre at best-shes not so stunning and her acting was just okish.The second half was specially prolonged unnecessarily.Chunni too was a let down from the epic chunni babu(jackie shroff).
Kalki Koechlin-She was the best actor in the movie,overshadowing abhay deol most of the time,she knew what she was supposed to do and did it.
One of the best part in the movie is when Dev asks paro to come to his hotel,after her marriage.Thats part compares what is now and what could have been.Nice,You dont quite like the movie in the hall but it grows on you.
Say thanks for the review and pay be all your money biatches.:\
Anurag kashyap has tried to slow down the movie for the mainstream public,and he kind of failed.he should stop doing it,if they can't understand it,let it be.Abhay deol is great,atleast one of the deols know how to act.Mahie gill was mediocre at best-shes not so stunning and her acting was just okish.The second half was specially prolonged unnecessarily.Chunni too was a let down from the epic chunni babu(jackie shroff).
Kalki Koechlin-She was the best actor in the movie,overshadowing abhay deol most of the time,she knew what she was supposed to do and did it.
One of the best part in the movie is when Dev asks paro to come to his hotel,after her marriage.Thats part compares what is now and what could have been.Nice,You dont quite like the movie in the hall but it grows on you.
Say thanks for the review and pay be all your money biatches.:\
Tickets booked for this weekend got to see this one.
got to see this one.
Just watched it today!You gotta give it to Anurag. He knows what he is doing!! Although the major character is high most of the time , it's not like Trainspotting or Requiem of a Dream!Perfect review has already been given by rhitwick, so no point in continuing!! Only thing i'll like to add is the cinematography , which is probably one the best in hindi cinema!!
@esumitkumar: Is that No Smoking in your avater I'm seeing brother??
@esumitkumar: Is that No Smoking in your avater I'm seeing brother??
^^ righty right my bruder..thats no smoking avatar
I saw the movie yesterday and it was awesome. The music perfectly complements the screenplay. I am already hooked on to it.
BTW one question (if i am not violating any TD rules). The movie is still not available on any of the torrents. Very surprising. Any clue why ??
But for this movie, please dont download it...go the the theater and watch...its worth it.
BTW one question (if i am not violating any TD rules). The movie is still not available on any of the torrents. Very surprising
. Any clue why ??But for this movie, please dont download it...go the the theater and watch...its worth it.
^^yeah!!!utv has done a good work in keeping predvd off the torrents!!
A
i think anurag is doing a lot of existential reading and thinking these days...
BTW one question (if i am not violating any TD rules). The movie is still not available on any of the torrents. Very surprising
You're absolutely right bro....well I have my exams on 16th so can't go to PVR's right now...
Well on torrents its a cam version..not worth watch..so im gonna rush to theatre this weekend..pretty hectic office work 
Must say that OST is goddamn awesome ! This is how an OST should be, and not something ghey like we have in other releasing movies.
Awesome movie! AK is one hell of a stud!!
This movie is simply mind blowing, ekdam hatke!! And please don't compare 'no smoking' and Dev D together. 'NO smoking' sucked badly.
Well either way, i liked it but my gf got bored. She had a typical answer " tum ladke logo hi yeh sabhi pasand ayega" lol.
Well either way, i liked it but my gf got bored. She had a typical answer " tum ladke logo hi yeh sabhi pasand ayega" lol.
^^ How No smoking sucked ???????? Elaborate
DEV D - 8/10
I watched DEV D night show ...ekdum rapchik picture..Abhay is becoming a class actor by choosing films like Oye lucky, Dev D,socha na tha etc
Movie is just like a Hollywood movie....OST damn gud...AK rocks !
Paro n Chanda mast hai re
PS : I really never knew that Devdas main ego prob thi b4 watching this movie
DEV D - 8/10
I watched DEV D night show ...ekdum rapchik picture..Abhay is becoming a class actor by choosing films like Oye lucky, Dev D,socha na tha etc
Movie is just like a Hollywood movie....OST damn gud...AK rocks !
Paro n Chanda mast hai re
PS : I really never knew that Devdas main ego prob thi b4 watching this movie
Correction.....Movie is just like a GREAT Hollywood movie
correction accepted
I watched that movie with my gf and we went for a night show and we had a pretty good fight before that so maybe because of that i couldn't enjoy the movie. lol :/