DIGIT-ARC read-only archive · snapshot: July 23, 2026

Branded HP systems do not accept Linux???

8 posts · originally from https://geek.digit.in/community/threads/branded-hp-systems-do-not-accept-linux.14145/

A
Aijaz Akhtar Original post #1
Aug 16, 2005 at 12:17 AM
This last week, there was a second experience with branded HP systems. earlier at one of the colleagues requested me to provide partitions in his HP Pavillion that had unpartitioned 80 GB HDD. I used some Linux CD (I think Yoper) to run QT Parted, and did the thing. But then Windows XP failed to boot. I installed Xandros in one partition that identified XP and offerred dual boot. Even then, the Windows did not boot, there was not even an error message. I tried to recover Windows boot through rescue mode of Mandrake, no success. And I had to return home. The next day I provided my laptop Recovery CD that offers Repair option to this man. (He had 8 Recovery CDs that offered repartitioning and reinstalling to recover the system). My colleague reported that he even re-installed Windows from my CD, still the boot continued to fail. I suspected that he bungled somewhere. Anyway, not depending on me, he called HP people who again used the 8 recovery CDs and the status quo is brought back, the lone 80 GB partition. And the HP man said that with XP, no other operating system can be installed!!!!
Then this week, in my office, the CISCO boy (CISCO is our netwroking agency) asked me the same thing. And I did the same on this HP infinity system, and later even after attempting to recover from Repair option of another Windows CD or installing Xandros twice, Windows boot has not come back. FixMBR did not work. What may have gone wrong is a different matter but why these branded systems prefer not to create partitions?? On my Fujitsu Siemens (Amio 2020) too had a single 40 GB partition.
However,. in another HP infinity, it had a Recover partition created by Unistall. Uninstalling that and removing that partitions through Windows Admin. tools (Disk management), I could do what I wanted (in fact this is the system that now has Xandros PLUS Ubuntu over that, a triple boot option!! But the same HP infinity is not accepting sany other OS!!
gauravnawani
Aug 18, 2005 at 5:57 PM
I do not think that there is any thing in HP that stops Linux from running. Some time it happes with the HDD(mostly samsung with me) that the MBR is not get written properly by Linux during the installation.

If that happens I will then boot into the rescue mode with the same distribution and reinstall GRUB after mounting the sysimage in RW mode, it works perfectly fine after that.
vignesh
vignesh #3
Aug 18, 2005 at 6:32 PM
Ubuntu has a specialized version for hp try it out.

*www.ubuntulinux.org/support/custom/
QwertyManiac
Aug 18, 2005 at 6:40 PM
Y did u post 2 posts buddie, u coul've edited...

Well , must be a Hwre compatiblity problem with ur HDD...
vignesh
vignesh #5
Aug 18, 2005 at 7:33 PM
Sorry man.I just pressed back and added the site.
A
Aug 19, 2005 at 10:26 AM
I installed Xandros as well as Ubuntu twice, but only the Windows boot loader went off. Even after attemtping to recover Windows, when the MBR was fixed, none booted, it showed OS not found.
vignesh
vignesh #7
Aug 19, 2005 at 6:39 PM
Did you edit the grub.list file in the /boot folder.
A
Aug 21, 2005 at 10:21 PM
Nope. I didn't edit ANY FILE. I in fact avoid opening console in front of total newbies when I promote OSS. And yes, I was wrong. One of the branded systewm wHCL,and not HP.