Fire xt vs wildfire s vs defy vs sony st315 vs spice mi410

A

hey folks!!!!!
which one of this would u suggest!!!all of this are at great price and i am quite confused.fire,wf,sony are all new and defy is quite old now...
which one of this should i pick.reply fast...i wanna buy it today itself
thanks :-?

Fire XT = front cam but slow processor (doesn't support adobe flash, officially)
Wildfire S = slow processor (same as above) + 3.2" screen but compact
Defy = getting old but still a good choice if able to find @ 14k or less.
Mini Pro = 3" vs 3.7". also read some comments: gsmarena
MI410 = if you are ready to stick to official Android 2.2 your whole life.

A

Sam said:
Fire XT = front cam but slow processor (doesn't support adobe flash, officially)
Wildfire S = slow processor (same as above) + 3.2" screen but compact
Defy = getting old but still a good choice if able to find @ 14k or less.
Mini Pro = 3" vs 3.7". also read some comments: gsmarena
MI410 = if you are ready to stick to official Android 2.2 your whole life.

so u meant to say that spice is k if i dont want to upgrade my device?
also i know 3' is bound to create some probs but that phone really packs a punch?how hard is it to type on that screen.also i am not a big fan of time scape
still dunno :cry:

Spice has already released Gingerbread officially for MI 410
Spice Mi-410 Gets Android 2.3.4 Gingerbread Update

Do check out Sony Xperia Neo V. I guess its specs will beat all the above phones and costing 16-17k.

A

so which one should i buy then

neo or defy... which one suits ur spec and budget.. dont go for spice, i have checked it from spice hotspot.. and its full of ****

MI410 does have a CM 7.1 port.. so the user can use that instead of the Spice provided one. But that's about the only ROM available for it.
agree with aritra... neo or defy... whichever suits your budget...

xperia mini - good camera,UI,Screen,1GHz procy etc.
or
wildfire S - Sense UI
which ever you desire.
Please avoid Spice. Though the specs look good, at the end of the day it's a SPICE.
IMO Brand matters a lot when it comes to phones. Phone is something that you want to showoff.
I think Defy also comes for the same price.
If you are ok with it, It's the best bet at that price.

Xpreria mini has 3" screen.. a little too small for me. Even my 3.7" Defy feels small while typing sometimes.

And for Sense, better to get Salsa than Wildfire S. Salsa has an A8 based chipset inside while Wildfire S doesnt.. AFAIK.
I'll stick to recommending Defy or Xperia Neo for now...

A

thanks a lot guys!!!atleast i can rule out spice and sony
what about fire xt?pls help me on that one
also heard that samsung has realsed galaxy y?

u can surely rule out fire over defy. because its not worth comparing

If you cant extend your budget to get a Neo, ur left with Defy. Fire xt has an inferior chipset compared to Defy.

A

but there is 2k difference between them?

There is... but trust me.. its worth it.

Defy's chipset is huge step ahead. 2K is actually less for the performance and features difference.
You can find Defy for 14K if you search hard on the streets.

A

but defy + is going to be launched soon so should we wait for it?
also there is one galaxy y launched and everyone is praising its specs?
is it worth?

Defy+ may get priced as high as 20k initially.

@7k, Galaxy Y is a good buy.

Galay Y is just 7K? :O Thats a decent phone for 7K then.
Any idea about its RAM amount and which chipset it uses?

Defy+ is available in ebay priced 21k. the little improvement over defy is not worth that much in my opinion

D

samsung galaxy Y is rs=6500 at letsbuy with coupon

defy+ looks over overpriced
do you guys thinks that flipkart are overpriced.

diagus said:
samsung galaxy Y is rs=6500 at letsbuy with coupon

defy+ looks over overpriced
do you guys thinks that flipkart are overpriced.

No dude i think the prices r good ... Letsbuy has some phones wich r priced a few hundred bucks below Flipkart's

flipcart gifts some free goodies and surprise gift for diwali too. so if the difference is not much then buying from flipkart is a good deal. just remember u can use coupon on letsbuy, but cant in flipkart

also i doubt lets buy offers COD for all locations. on one instance i check for COD & it was disabled after applying coupon code.

Soumik said:
Galay Y is just 7K? :O Thats a decent phone for 7K then.
Any idea about its RAM amount and which chipset it uses?

According to gsmarena, Galaxy Y has 256MB which is pretty low IMO(maybe 384MB would have been better or am I asking too much for its price :))

.
Dunno about chipset but the phone runs on an ARMv6 832MHz processor so maybe the chipset is Qulacomm MSM7227.

^^ Yeah probably right...
Still... i guess for something less than 7K, its definitely acceptable. Its a nice pricing.

yes for 6.5k in letsbuy, its perfectly acceptable

@sam, coupons are not allowed in case of COD

@btwn soumik congrats for 420th post (chuckle)

Thanks aritra.. please dont mark me with my post number... con isnt my way of life

just kiddin mate..

A

u have any reviews about galaxy y?i am really inclined towards fire xt as it has a front cam!!!

hvn't checked any aditya.. will check and let ya know tonight

A

thanks

check it out aditya

Samsung S5360 Galaxy Y preview: First look - GSMArena.com

A

what is the sar value of fire xt