Indian Idol Or Sa Re Ga Ma Pa ?

Hey Buddies,

as the title suggest , which one's better in terms of quality of talent ?

For me , Sa Re Ga Ma Pa anytime ~

BlackBerry7100g.

i have watched only one episode of Indian Idol, and i felt it was more of a comedy show.

@Blackberry: Add "none of these" options. I will choose that one.

A

Sa Re Ga Ma!!!

Indian Idol.... my classmate had been till last 7...... just one mediocre performance....he was out.

dunno abt Sa re ga ma.....
but the one done by star plus is full of $hit.

OMG...Contest 50 -50 till now...

abhi_10_20 said:
Indian Idol.... my classmate had been till last 7...... just one mediocre performance....he was out.

may i know which 1 ?

none of this

None.
American Idol

Indian Idol is a bunch of jokers.

SaReGaMa is a platform for Himesh to talk all his crap.

^

Youre right.
And how can you forget Anu Malik. Talks like he is the champ when it comes to Music Direction.

R

And how can you forget Anu Malik. Talks like he is the champ when it comes to Music Direction.

he reminds my of Ross the intern of the Tonight Show

as for the poll none of these but i have to admit i have to watch I.I. with my family when having dinner

ratedrsuperstar said:
he reminds my of Ross the intern of the Tonight Show

as for the poll none of these but i have to admit i have to watch I.I. with my family when having dinner

lol right Indian Idol is a family show where u can have a laugh with your family members.Better watch The Great Indian laughter challenge.

Anu malik sometimes acts like an idiot, the show is full of crap, if one judge likes the singer then the other judge hates him, & its viz...
hate to watch both shows.

i watch indian idol but that zee prog is certainly better.

on sony,Emon,Chang are good(for me)

but today some one sang vande mataram(AR Rehman) on zee's show,and i was lucky to listen to it.he is an amazing talent

these shows are good platform

I dont watch any of it, by friend talks about Voice of India too much...(Gives me headache...), My friends says Indian Idol is crap and SaReGaMa dont have talented singers.
I liked American Idol but its ended.
When it comes to talent shows I am watching "On The Lot" , better then anything. (The Apprentice is good too.)

:::--- Some of my friends says I look like Emon...
Who is he? I have a faint idea that he must be from one of these shows we are talking about. Can someone post a pic of him? ;-)

^^American Idol starts every January

mayanks_098 said:
but today some one sang vande mataram(AR Rehman) on zee's show,and i was lucky to listen to it.he is an amazing talent

Thts Raja Hasan..amazing !

Yeah Raja Hasan and Aneek Dhar are the best.

Musicians ki nautanki , neechtaa ka pradarshan, aapas me jhagda, ghatiapan. Indian television was already dead because of saas bahu , this type of shows kicked the dead body in the grave.

tarey_g said:
Musicians ki nautanki , neechtaa ka pradarshan, aapas me jhagda, ghatiapan. Indian television was already dead because of saas bahu , this type of shows kicked the dead body in the grave.

No no its not in grave its hanging like in your avatar.

N

Saregampa is much better with lot talented singers. I wonder what's the definition of Sur according to Malik and Aisha? Both learned different sur of music? They disagree with one saying he is in sur and other saying not in sur. How on earth it can be possible? A person can either be in sur or not in sur.

navjotjsingh said:
Saregampa is much better with lot talented singers. I wonder what's the definition of Sur according to Malik and Aisha? Both learned different sur of music?

Yeah ..totally agree with u !

So finally Indian Idol won ? :shock:

it's 50-50

Both the shows are huge waste of time. Nothing but load of crap.

Damm i could only balance the contest. IMHO SaReGaMaPa got a lot more talent then Indian Idol. and the program does not contain as much Nautanki as Indian Idol has.

N

Currently Saregamapa is ahead of indian idol.

A

sare gama pa rocks..and if any of you hasn't still seen it, pls do see....and listen to wats important like the songs etc..not wat himesh has to say...U shud know be4 doing anything that wat do u want and see only dat not the fuss going around..

Once more Sa re ga ma pa rocks

Ya , Sa Re Ga Ma Paa Rocks !

sa re ga ma pa rules guys...star voice howevr has sum really gud singers......but th presentation is crap...the judges in star voice are howevr bttr...

so saregamapa=talent+presentation+cartoon(himesh)=complete package...