DIGIT-ARC read-only archive · snapshot: July 23, 2026

India's first spacecraft to Mars successfully put into Earth's orbit !

136 posts · originally from https://geek.digit.in/community/threads/indias-first-spacecraft-to-mars-successfully-put-into-earths-orbit.179176/

Vyom
Vyom Original post #1
Nov 5, 2013 at 8:47 PM
India launches first mission to Mars

*www.livemint.com/rf/Image-621x414/LiveMint/Period1/2013/11/05/Photos/mars_mission_scientists.jpg
Scientists and engineers working on a Mars Orbiter vehicle at Isro’s satellite centre in Bangalore.​

NEW DELHI (AP) — India on Tuesday launched its first spacecraft bound for Mars, a complex mission that it hopes will demonstrate and advance technologies for space travel.

Hundreds of people watched the rocket carrying the Mars orbiter take off from the east-coast island of Sriharikota and streak across the sky. Many more across the country watched live TV broadcasts.

Officials at the space center described it as a "textbook launch." If the mission is successful, India will become only the fourth nation to visit the red planet after the Soviet Union, the United States and Europe.

"Capturing and igniting the young minds of India and across the globe will be the major return from this mission," mission director P. Kunhikrishnan said from the launch site.

After 44 minutes, the orbiter separated from the rocket and entered into an elliptical path around Earth. Over the next 20-25 days, it will perform a series of technical maneuvers and short burns to raise its orbit before it slingshots toward Mars.

"With teamwork and the kind of dedication we have today, any mission is not beyond our capability," said S. Ramakrishnan, head of the space center and launch authorization board.

The 3,000-pound orbiter Mangalyaan, which means "Mars craft" in Hindi, must travel 485 million miles over 300 days to reach an orbit around the red planet next September.

"The biggest challenge will be precisely navigating the spacecraft to Mars," said K. Radhakrishnan, chairman of the Indian Space and Research Organization. "We will know if we pass our examination on Sept. 24, 2014."

He congratulated the scientists for putting the mission together "in a very limited time." The project began after the space agency carried out a feasibility study in 2010 after successfully launching a lunar satellite in 2008. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh announced the planned voyage to Mars only last year during his annual address to the nation.

"It's a really big thing for India!" said 13-year-old Pratibha Maurya, who gathered with her father and about 50 others to watch the launch at the Nehru Planetarium in New Delhi.

Some have questioned the $72 million price tag for a country of 1.2 billion people still dealing with widespread hunger and poverty. But the government defended the Mars mission, and its $1 billion space program in general, by noting its importance in providing high-tech jobs for scientists and engineers and practical applications in solving problems on Earth.

Decades of space research have allowed India to develop satellite, communications and remote sensing technologies that are helping to solve everyday problems at home, from forecasting where fish can be caught by fishermen to predicting storms and floods.

"These missions are important. These are things that give Indians happiness and bragging rights," said Raghu Kalra of the Amateur Astronomers Association Delhi. "Even a poor person, when he learns that my country is sending a mission to another planet, he will feel a sense of pride for his country, and he will want to make it a better place."

The orbiter will gather images and data that will help in determining how Martian weather systems work and what happened to the large quantities of water that are believed to have once existed on Mars. It also will search Mars for methane, a key chemical in life processes that could also come from geological processes. Experts say the data will improve understanding about how planets form, what conditions might make life possible and where else in the universe it might exist.

The orbiter is expected to have at least six months to investigate the planet's landscape and atmosphere. At its closest point it will be 227 miles from the planet's surface, and its furthest point will be 49,700 miles away.



Source: *www.usatoday.com/story/news/world/2013/11/05/india-mars-mission/3440267/

Source 2: A giant leap for Isro - Livemint
V
V.VAIDYA #2
Nov 5, 2013 at 10:14 PM
India Rising!
Hrishi
Hrishi #3
Nov 6, 2013 at 12:43 AM
While it's good that India has successfully setup something forward like this comparing itself to the league of developed nations.

"It still doesn't makes sense how a hungry , poverty ridden , sick person would take pride in this."
I think he should have given a better explanation about the possibilities it'll bring insteading of bringing the concept of Pride for a poor.

BTW , the interesting news is that the Indians were able to acheive the mission objectives in almost 1/6th the cost of a similar mission that could be taken by NASA.
reddick
reddick #4
Nov 6, 2013 at 12:54 PM
I wish ISRO Best of Luck for their mission and hope for it's accurate accomplishment. Jai Ho!
.jRay.
.jRay. #5
Nov 6, 2013 at 1:07 PM
India FTW..
CommanderShawnzer
Nov 6, 2013 at 2:05 PM
No Anti-Indian 'intelligent' hipster comments?




Anyhoo,back to topic
GJ ISRO:clap2::clap2:,Next put a man on Mars before them Chineses
vijju6091
Nov 6, 2013 at 3:52 PM
go ISRO GO:)
Darth Vader
Nov 6, 2013 at 5:25 PM
Some have questioned the $72 million price tag for a country of 1.2 billion people still dealing with widespread hunger and poverty.

Bahahahaha !!!!
Not sure how much millions is looted by politicians and spent on Religious crap everyday despite hunger/poverty.

Science is the only thing that solved/cured/saved millions of lives since the beginning of mankind and questioning its progress and benefits towards mankind is ridiculous !!!
quagmire
Nov 6, 2013 at 6:40 PM
Look at the comments on the page : India launches first mission to Mars

So India gets foreign aid yet has a space program? They have millions of people in poverty but do this? Absolutely disgusting.

Just another country entering the pissing contest.

now if they would stop accepting gang rape

people are dying on the streets in every corner of india and they received foreign aid to launch spacecraft on Mars??? Is this joke right?

No word yet on whether or not India finally had to call US for tech support on this project...

What an obscene waste of money and resources that would be better spent on sewer system infrastructure.

Good for India now perhaps we need not give the country aid, if we still do that is.

Scouting for yet another "call center" location I suppose.

Millions illiterate and in poverty and India has a space program?


FU B@$tards.!
CommanderShawnzer
Nov 6, 2013 at 6:50 PM
Look at the comments on the page : India launches first mission to Mars




















FU B@$tards.!
BREAKING NEWS!!!!!!
80% Of those commenters are wanna be White-Person Indian immigrants for sure

BTW,WTF we RECIEVE Aid?I thought we GIVE aid to Porkistan,Sri Lanka,Nepal,BorderjumperDesh and a bunch of Poor Africa counries
quagmire
quagmire #11
Nov 6, 2013 at 6:53 PM
If the Indian scientists at NASA right now (who reportedly contribute 36% of the workforce) had decided to work for ISRO, we could have seen this day 30 years ago..
Anorion
Anorion #14
Nov 6, 2013 at 7:39 PM
Look at the comments on the page : India launches first mission to Mars

If the mission is successful, India will become only the fourth nation to visit the red planet after the Soviet Union, the United States and Europe.
:facepalm: :banghead:
G
Nov 6, 2013 at 9:00 PM
Congrats Isro.


On a lighter
*pbs.twimg.com/media/BYTfDhACcAABGKh.jpg:large
icebags
icebags #18
Nov 6, 2013 at 10:01 PM
Atleast,We did it before the Chineses

yet to go a long way , my friend, chinese sat died while reaching earth orbit, our has reached the orbit, now lets all hope it will gather enough velocity on the scheduled day to get a proper slingshot towards mars.

first test is passed, 2nd test is waiting, after that there will be some unknown number of tests where isro have never set foot before. we can only pray for the best. :)

russians failed numerous times, japan tried once and failed, and some nasa probes just vanished, eu have a better record probably.

:sad:
Pride in Country
Lost

well, govt doesn't take donations from anyone. but it doesn't forbid anyone from taking the same. free country free people, if some orgs seek funding through donations, govt doesn't really mind.
CommanderShawnzer
Nov 6, 2013 at 10:07 PM
yet to go a long way , my friend, chinese sat died while reaching earth orbit, our has reached the orbit, now lets all hope it will gather enough velocity on the scheduled day to get a proper slingshot towards mars.

first test is passed, 2nd test is waiting, after that there will be some unknown number of tests where isro have never set foot before. we can only pray for the best. :)

russians failed numerous times, japan tried once and failed, and some nasa probes just vanished, eu have a better record probably.

Martians! I knew it! They Live underground!
icebags
icebags #20
Nov 6, 2013 at 10:24 PM
^ i just remembered, ussr is history, and russia never tried another mars exploration after its first failure in post soviet era. so, if india succeeds, it will become the 2nd single country with proven mars probing capability - 3rd single country in the history of mankind.

considering eu isn't a country.

once successful, if isro can launch missions like these cheap, i guess there will be a big business opportunity waiting in future.
$hadow
$hadow #21
Nov 7, 2013 at 5:26 PM
One thing #respect for what they did. Managed the whole thing by themselves let's just hope for its success.
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #22
Nov 7, 2013 at 8:14 PM
Proud to be Indian ,Pride for all of us Friends,Pranaam to my Motherland.

Salutations ISRO!!!

But we must really rejoice,the next year after MOM(Mars Orbiter Module) is successfully put to the designated trajectory/orbit around Mars for experiments and exploring.

Meanwhile,it's a long and very complex journey for MOM with arduous tasks for the Scientists/Technologists and Engineers at ISRO in the coming days ahead.

Checking...Corrections...Maneuver...Checking...Corrections...Maneuver... :---------------------------------------> ~ 24th September 2014...
S
shade1 #24
Nov 7, 2013 at 8:39 PM
:mrgreen::mrgreen: this is absolutely great for India.Space exploration is being done at at a painfully slow rate throughout the globe .Ever since the apollo missions no significant manned mission has been attempted:|.Reasons of extreme costs and lack of interest have been given.Funding for nasa and isro has also been very low for many years(though it was never high for isro).A few facts remain that earth will slowly become difficult to live in ,that is ultimately after probably a billion years completely uninhabitable.There has not been a specific research and its also very difficult to know but the fact remains.All this money in space exploration will ultimately give huge returns in the long run and take us forward.I hope huge benefits come out of the mission to mine asteroids ,these resources will certainly be a game changer for us.:razz: .If there ever was any doubt about India's technological capability in space ,then it has been removed by this successful mission.
S
Nov 7, 2013 at 10:39 PM
How many countries put a man on the moon??
deepakkrishnan
Nov 7, 2013 at 10:45 PM
^^ After watching the discovery documentary about the Neil Armstrong trip .. I believe "Zilch - nada - 0 "
S
Nov 7, 2013 at 11:33 PM
I have tied my iphone to my diwali rocket and launched it on the day of diwali. It must have went past earth orbit now and must be on its way to mars orbit. Anyway when you see high resolution images of mars in instagram a year from now you can bet assure that it was my phone sending those images.
CommanderShawnzer
Nov 7, 2013 at 11:38 PM
I have tied my iphone to my diwali rocket and launched it on the day of diwali. It must have went past earth orbit now and must be on its way to mars orbit. Anyway when you see high resolution images of mars in instagram a year from now you can bet assure that it was my phone sending those images.

Sarcasm Phail
Your rocket bursted,therefore grilling your iPhone/
Hrishi
Hrishi #31
Nov 8, 2013 at 12:00 AM
I have tied my iphone to my diwali rocket and launched it on the day of diwali. It must have went past earth orbit now and must be on its way to mars orbit. Anyway when you see high resolution images of mars in instagram a year from now you can bet assure that it was my phone sending those images.

No , it won't . In fact , the rocket won't even take off , unless it's powered by iMacFuel. :rofl:
Extreme Gamer
Nov 8, 2013 at 1:27 AM
One thing #respect for what they did. Managed the whole thing by themselves let's just hope for its success.

They have deep space communications and tracking assistance from NASA. Mostly back-end stuff.
skeletor
skeletor #33
Nov 8, 2013 at 1:35 AM
ISRO always does our country proud.
a_k_s_h_a_y
Nov 8, 2013 at 7:54 AM
You win! LOL
I have tied my iphone to my diwali rocket and launched it on the day of diwali. It must have went past earth orbit now and must be on its way to mars orbit. Anyway when you see high resolution images of mars in instagram a year from now you can bet assure that it was my phone sending those images.
S
Nov 8, 2013 at 2:10 PM
What about the theory that US never went to moon. They faked all moon missions.
$hadow
$hadow #36
Nov 8, 2013 at 11:24 PM
Well but to be said we are Indians are so much happy for Deewali that we even sent a rocket to Mars to show our happiness and joy :-D :-D :-D.
icebags
icebags #37
Nov 8, 2013 at 11:36 PM
^ hopefully the biggest rocket of this diwali will succeed.

meanwhile MAVEN going through the last phase preparations and getting ready for launch scheduled on november 18th. it be directly propelled towards mars instead of being slingshot with multiple turns like MOM.

*i.imgur.com/nKxnPtu.jpg
sushovan
sushovan #39
Nov 9, 2013 at 8:30 AM
:lol:
*i.imgur.com/NmnOxHh.jpg:large
S
Nov 9, 2013 at 2:24 PM
Indian public can go without air for days. They can also survive without food and water for days. They are the perfect astronauts.
bssunilreddy
Nov 9, 2013 at 5:49 PM
I am proud to be called a Nellorian as it is my native place where Sriharikota Space Port is located but I never visited it in my life.:p
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #44
Nov 9, 2013 at 7:21 PM
^Very Good and you should be proud of. :)
Except that you can visit to that Highly Secured and Classified location, if you achieve to become a Higher Govt. of India Official(mainly belonging to Ministry of Space/Home/Defense) that too under special authorization/permissions and/or recommendations...:wink:
Hrishi
Hrishi #45
Nov 9, 2013 at 11:13 PM
these people who work at such places must be talented enough. Devoting their entire life to science. That's actually life , away from Materialism and all the wordly sh1t.
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #46
Nov 10, 2013 at 1:15 PM
these people who work at such places must be talented enough. Devoting their entire life to science. That's actually life , away from Materialism and all the wordly sh1t.
Is it so?
I think it is not entirely true. Truly the Scientists/Technologists/Engineers working there are much devoted and dextrous than other experts,but sometimes lust overcomes dedication and service to motherland.One of the reasons for delay in projects as in case of indigenous development of GSLV systems,which we are unsuccessful till far today.
Lust means,legally some of these talented people move over to morrreee greener pastures,such as joining at MNC's for lucrative posts & careers.
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #47
Nov 12, 2013 at 7:25 AM
A glitch occured in the 4th stage of upliftment for the MOM around Earth's orbit...:-( ,but Scientists and Engineers are claiming it to be a minor glitch...saying that won't affect the MOM towards its journey to Mars.
Extreme Gamer
Nov 12, 2013 at 7:19 PM
A glitch occured in the 4th stage of upliftment for the MOM around Earth's orbit...:-( ,but Scientists and Engineers are claiming it to be a minor glitch...saying that won't affect the MOM towards its journey to Mars.

They said the orbit got successfully raised.

Anyway, the path that they're taking, worst case the orbiter will return to earth after missing mars or missing the window to leave earth's sphere of influence. I hope they prepared for that eventuality - it helps learn a lot for the next mission.
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #49
Nov 13, 2013 at 6:54 AM
^Keeping our Fingers crossed and praying to GOD,let's Hope for the Best of success.

If all goes well...by Dec 1(2013),MOM will journey towards Mars...leaving Earth's gravitational influence...
$hadow
$hadow #50
Nov 13, 2013 at 11:33 AM
India is all set to make a statement to others that See what we can do. #repect and hope for the successful journey.
harshilsharma63
Nov 13, 2013 at 3:32 PM
India is all set to make a statement to others that See what we can do. #repect and hope for the successful journey.

Answer from NASA: What we already did.
CommanderShawnzer
Nov 13, 2013 at 3:37 PM
In their heart of hearts everyone knows that this will fail. :lol:
Nothing to see here and act like a douche,people
This satellite will go MIA,possibly abducted by aliens to gauge the scientific prowess of their soon to be 1.2Bn slaves
The last sentence was a joke. :EDI:
skeletor
skeletor #53
Nov 13, 2013 at 5:00 PM
^ check out what happened to China's Mars mission. Yinghuo-1 - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
S
Nov 13, 2013 at 6:00 PM
Dont worry guys even if this fail my diwali rocket with iphone attached wont fail. I saw in google earth that it has already left earth orbit. Unlike other rockets mine doesnt orbit earth it just goes straight to mars why waste time orbiting earth
Mr.Kickass
Nov 13, 2013 at 8:58 PM
[Newsflash] Mangalyaan mission finds huge stretch of Mars land already owned by Robert Vadra
Hrishi
Hrishi #56
Nov 13, 2013 at 9:09 PM
^ check out what happened to China's Mars mission. Yinghuo-1 - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Chinese : Chale toh Chand tak , warna shaam tak. :p
Mr.Kickass
Nov 15, 2013 at 11:28 PM
[IMGG]*www.thinkdigit.com/forum/attachment.php?attachmentid=12712&d=1384538244[/IMGG]

SmartPlanet
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #59
Nov 30, 2013 at 9:44 AM
If all goes well according to schedule, then after midnight today,MOM (Mars Orbiter Module)will bid farewell to Earth's gravitational field,and embark on a long journey towards Mars...ahead...
Let's hope and wish for the best.
Salutations ISRO.
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #61
Nov 30, 2013 at 9:52 AM
^Don't mix politics with Technology.
We may fail or succeed but the path taken or followed is the primary aspect.
bssunilreddy
Nov 30, 2013 at 9:56 AM
We should reach Mars is our goal man and don't compare with others.
How much scientific and technological might left India and still we are able to achieve something at a fraction of our big brother's budget right.
Even this is not possible without the help of many in the international community and its a collective effort as we lack some resources.
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #63
Nov 30, 2013 at 3:16 PM
We should reach Mars is our goal man and don't compare with others.
How much scientific and technological might left India and still we are able to achieve something at a fraction of our big brother's budget right.
Even this is not possible without the help of many in the international community and its a collective effort as we lack some resources.
Never comparing with NASA which are eons ahead or with ESA which are also ahead.It is also foolish to compare with the Chinese ,who are really doing some serious Scientific + Technological work,leaving aside manufacturing of crappy to Premium quality electronics hardware products.
The last para of yours emphasizes a True fact,which cannot be ignored nor to be ashamed off.
icebags
icebags #64
Dec 1, 2013 at 12:31 AM
catch latest updates from here:

*www.facebook.com/isromom?directed_target_id=0
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #65
Dec 1, 2013 at 10:37 AM
^Thanks @icebags for the link, at least we(ISRO) made it successfully to the First and Primary step of this voyage.
Now:---> checking...corrections in trajectory ...tracking help from DSN(Deep Space Network)by JPL(Jet Propulsion Laboratory)NASA is the schedule for Indian Scientists ahead...
icebags
icebags #66
Dec 1, 2013 at 11:57 PM
and today chang'e has been launched with a long march 3 rocket for a lunar landing mission. *static.d-addicts.com/da/forum/images/smiles/icon_salut.gif

here is the video of engine ignition video for trans orbit injection. they should have installed similar cam on MOM too, just some lightweight vga webcam/fone cam would have been sufficient for this. :D

kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #67
Dec 3, 2013 at 7:07 AM
MOM,flew passed by the orbit of Moon,as confirmed by ISRO.
Now destination Mars.
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #68
Dec 25, 2013 at 10:36 AM
MOM moving successfully towards Mars,trajectory corrections O.K. for first phase.It's under the Sun's gravitational influence(Heliocentric pull/push),and doing well.
Everything is functioning and running as per schedule and normal.
Vyom
Vyom #69
Dec 25, 2013 at 12:35 PM
You are truly following this mission. Thanks for the updates.
It sure looks like will reach Mars within less than one year! :doublethumb:
rijinpk1
rijinpk1 #70
Dec 25, 2013 at 12:37 PM
You are truly following this mission. Thanks for the updates.
It sure looks like will reach Mars within less than one year! :doublethumb:

let us pray. it will sure do what it was meant for ;)
harshilsharma63
Dec 25, 2013 at 8:01 PM
They didn't inscribed our names like NASA did with the Mars Rover :(
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #72
Aug 27, 2014 at 3:56 PM
Already successfully accomplished Trajectory Correction Manoeuvre of MOM on June 11th.

Source : Mars Orbiter Mission trajectory correction manoeuvre on June 11 - The Times of India

Now just a month ahead when the most difficult part of this mission will be tested,even difficult than liftoff to space.
Let us pray for our MOM :-- Of India,By India to be a major success...

Source : Mars Orbiter Mission: India?s ?giant leap? a month away - The Times of India
TechnoBOY
TechnoBOY #73
Sep 20, 2014 at 9:47 AM
Already successfully accomplished Trajectory Correction Manoeuvre of MOM on June 11th.

Source : Mars Orbiter Mission trajectory correction manoeuvre on June 11 - The Times of India

Now just a month ahead when the most difficult part of this mission will be tested,even difficult than liftoff to space.
Let us pray for our MOM :-- Of India,By India to be a major success...

Source : Mars Orbiter Mission: India?s ?giant leap? a month away - The Times of India
:clap2::bananana:
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #74
Sep 23, 2014 at 9:11 AM
Entered the Mars Gravitational sphere of influence...CLAPS TO OUR SCIENTISTS + ENGINEERS,who have painstalkingly nurturing and functioning the mission.
By tomorrow, MOM may be put in on the elleptical orbit around Mars.

Source : India's MOM enters Mars Gravitational Sphere of Influence | News Nation
skeletor
skeletor #75
Sep 23, 2014 at 2:11 PM
National Holiday should be declared on 25th upon successful orbital insertion on 24th.
icebags
icebags #77
Sep 23, 2014 at 10:15 PM
^ so it's tomorrow at last..... need to wake up in the morning.

but 25th should be declared more like national hard working day, to honour the restless hard work the isro did to do something like this.
:)
will there be any live updates on radio / tv ?
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #78
Sep 24, 2014 at 7:10 PM
-----SUCCESS OF INDIA-----



For the people.
By the people.
Of the people
.



----SALUTATIONS to ISRO----
Vyom
Vyom #82
Sep 24, 2014 at 11:38 PM
Congrats to ISRO. For making the ride to Mars costing lower than Autos! :p
:doublethumb:

Btw, National holiday since India's rover reached Mars? Come on.. if they start giving holiday's for every accomplishment India achieves, soon we will run out of "Working days". xD
skeletor
skeletor #83
Sep 24, 2014 at 11:41 PM
^^ err, I don't mean a National Holiday for this thing every year, but only once. ;)
Hrishi
Hrishi #84
Sep 25, 2014 at 12:26 AM
Well its nice to see feats like these being achieved by our indigenously built technology.
I was wondering , is this craft supposed to land on mars ? If yes , then that's the most critical phase , right ?
Landing on mars is extremely difficult. Isn't?
Nerevarine
Sep 25, 2014 at 12:27 AM
India is the first country in Asia and fourth in the world to perform a successful Mars mission, and the only one to do so on the first attempt.


Great JOB ISRO !
Also, INB4 BUTTHURT UK citizens commenting, "This is where our tax payer's money goes, to aid in a foreign space program" ?

- - - Updated - - -

Well its nice to see feats like these being achieved by our indigenously built technology.
I was wondering , is this craft supposed to land on mars ? If yes , then that's the most critical phase , right ?
Landing on mars is extremely difficult. Isn't?

AFAIK, no, its gonna revolve around the planet.. collecting data on the atmosphere
icebags
icebags #86
Sep 25, 2014 at 12:38 AM
Well its nice to see feats like these being achieved by our indigenously built technology.
I was wondering , is this craft supposed to land on mars ? If yes , then that's the most critical phase , right ?
Landing on mars is extremely difficult. Isn't?

^ it wont hurt as much as it would to jump into earth from orbit.

India is the first country in Asia and fourth in the world to perform a successful Mars mission, and the only one to do so on the first attempt.

correction, 2nd existing country in world.

considering soviet russia doesn't exist anymore, and eu is not a country. :D
P
Sep 26, 2014 at 9:35 AM
Mean while western countries are not able to digest the success of India.
srkmish
srkmish #88
Sep 26, 2014 at 10:03 AM
Great. A vicarious way to feel good.
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #89
Sep 26, 2014 at 11:34 AM
Great. A vicarious way to feel good.
Absolutely.

Meanwhile as per latest news all instruments onboard MOM are functioning exactly as per Text Book Guidance and Schedule,as confirmed by Scientists and Engineers of ISRO. Data and information are flowing in at Bangalore,Ahmedabad,etc. the various locations of ISRO in our Country...
Nerevarine
Sep 26, 2014 at 3:02 PM
Mean while western countries are not able to digest the success of India.

exactly, just look at all the hate comments UK commentors posted..
"This is where our tax payer's money goes ? to help a third world country excel in space program"

The butthurt is real, too real
$hadow
$hadow #91
Sep 26, 2014 at 3:08 PM
Foreign media is pissed of on the success of India.
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #92
Sep 26, 2014 at 3:18 PM
^+1 for this.
icebags
icebags #93
Sep 30, 2014 at 2:30 AM
our own mars pic, with isro mark. :)

*planetary.s3.amazonaws.com/assets/images/4-mars/2014/20140929_1669791_1557930277763662_2002345568908420485_o.jpg

thats said to be a huge dust storm over north pole there. :shock:
vedula.k95
Oct 4, 2014 at 10:56 AM
No you have to pay extra dollar for fuel kits :lol:

- - - Updated - - -

No you have to pay extra dollar for fuel kits :lol:

No you have to pay extra dollar for fuel kits
Vyom
Vyom #95
Oct 24, 2014 at 10:16 AM
Google giving its homage to Mar's orbital completing one month in Mars orbit: :D

*media2.intoday.in/indiatoday/images/stories/mangalyan-650_102414041618.jpg
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #96
Oct 24, 2014 at 1:21 PM
Yes, 1 month revolution around Mars and other functionary mission, safely + successfully completed by MOM ,courtesy ISRO of India.:clap2::goodjob:
Skyh3ck
Skyh3ck #97
Nov 16, 2014 at 7:23 PM
bumping this thread, as Interstellar movie has mention of Indian space program and solar cell from India, i think our success in space programs are being noticed very well by western intellectuals, Nolan is one of the renowed and highly intelligent director of our time, and if his movie mentions about any space agency other than NASA its a great thing.

how many here actually planning to go for ISRO jobs, waiting for a day when Indians will set foot on another planet on their own technology

- - - Updated - - -

also watch this if you have time

icebags
icebags #98
Nov 16, 2014 at 7:50 PM
^ it's not better, get this clear o, both have different missions. ours was on an engineering mission to test our capabilities to actually reach their - with some top up basic science equips. nasa has already achieved this goal, theres all are on serious science missions. u will understand if u just look at the payload specs.
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #99
Nov 16, 2014 at 8:04 PM
Year 2018 already marked for MOM-II mission.
Probability of dropping an instrumental module (or a lander module!!!) onto the Martian surface.
Vyom
Vyom #100
Nov 25, 2014 at 8:28 PM
Mangalyaan have been featured in Time's list of "The 25 Best Inventions of 2014". :)
The 25 Best Inventions of 2014

On second position.

*i.minus.com/iwd68jCNUMDzy.JPG
doomgiver
doomgiver #101
Nov 25, 2014 at 11:15 PM
lets get it straight a few facts :

1. this is 2014, not 1980's. we have much more advanced tech available to us, PLUS, all the cumulative experience of all the previous successful or failed mars missions (its called "knowledge", in case you were wondering)
2. the orbiter carries simple instruments, hence low cost. try putting a rover or an entire damned chemical lab into it, and cost will skyrocket.
3. putting something into orbit is not too hard, you just gotta have good maths.

everyone is acting like this is a freaking HUGE thing, and we've done something so freaking radical, that everything forever will be changed by this.
we DIDNT do anything brilliant.
brilliant would have been putting a rover-type thing on mars on the first try, but our scientists are too pussy for that.

sure, its a nice achievement. but its nothing big, or groundbreaking.

we're just repeating stuff which was done 20 years ago with today's tech.

its like racing against a maruti 800 in a ferrari, and feeling proud you beat them. it was just as expected.

dont blow up your egos too much, we're still YEARS behind NASA.
srkmish
srkmish #102
Nov 26, 2014 at 12:10 AM
I have to say that is a very negative attitude. the amount of cost involved is still by any means not less and the precise engineering involved is a testament to its functioning well. All in all. projects like these are always a risk. Just last month 2 rockets got destroyed seconds after launch even if this "advanced tech" and "experience" is there for us to tap.
doomgiver
doomgiver #103
Nov 26, 2014 at 1:27 AM
im negative because its being blown out of proportion. mars missions are a common thing. hell, even japan has done one(even tho it ran out of fuel).

List of missions to Mars - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

if this was done 10 years back, THEN it'd be spectacular. This is too little, too late.
Anorion
Anorion #104
Nov 26, 2014 at 1:38 AM
if it is followed up with more missions, with a higher capacity launch vehicle, more sensors, and puts to full use a bigger budget, then its a good thing
doomgiver
doomgiver #105
Nov 26, 2014 at 3:06 AM
if it is followed up with more missions, with a higher capacity launch vehicle, more sensors, and puts to full use a bigger budget, then its a good thing

^this!!

atm, its just a pissing contest. it doesnt even have a spectrometer, iirc. bah, space "probe".
Gollum
Gollum #106
Nov 26, 2014 at 5:24 AM
Mangalyaan have been featured in Time's list of "The 25 Best Inventions of 2014". :)
The 25 Best Inventions of 2014

On second position.

*i.minus.com/iwd68jCNUMDzy.JPG

All I can say
bad cable management :p
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #107
Nov 26, 2014 at 7:45 AM
No fools are comparing ISRO with NASA!!!!!!!!!!!!
In a country like ours where we are still a developing economy and a 3rd World country according to Global Standards...where we are plagued by poverty,illiterate people and above all corruption,with Govt. apathy towards research and funding projects IT IS A GREAT FEAT AND ACHIEVEMENT THAT MAKES US PROUD.

Why are we comparing us with Japan or U.S. when our ECONOMY is much behind them???????????????

Still with a crippled economy and frowning upon by the Mighty EAST(China) and the WESTERN countries, ISRO has gone to leaps and bounds. This is the truth.

Negative attitude against the country and Howling , by sitting in Glass Houses ,only makes one vulnerable to themselves.
doomgiver
doomgiver #108
Nov 26, 2014 at 7:56 AM
Negative attitude against the country and Howling , by sitting in Glass Houses ,only makes one vulnerable to themselves.

Overconfidence has ruined more people than humility.
Anorion
Anorion #109
Nov 26, 2014 at 2:46 PM
well no one is focusing on the shortcomings and only celebrating
This was basically a mission for figuring out the technology required to send the orbiter to mars, the actual scientific objectives were secondary
Welcome To Indian Space Research Organisation - Mars Orbiter Mission

The PSLV is meant for only light payloads, and is not enough for launching anything really useful in today's standards. Say for launching satellites for other countries, we need a higher capacity launch vehicle.
1 payload was dropped to keep orbiter light - The Times of India
There were compromises made to keep the orbiter light

The orbiter had to choose between an elliptical orbit, with a longer life, and a closer orbit that could get more scientific data but with less life. It chose the elliptical orbit.

and why get all proud because it was cheap
the "cheapness" was forced upon Isro because of earlier failures. The smaller, older Polar Satellite Launch Vehicle (PSLV) had to be deployed, rather than the more powerful Geosynchronous Satellite Launch Vehicle (GSLV), because Isro had failed to stabilise the GSLV's cryogenic technology in time to launch into a favourable Earth-Mars window. The payload for the Mars orbiter had to be considerably reduced as a result. The trajectory also became more complicated because the PSLV lacks the power to take a more direct route. A GSLV-based Mars mission would have cost more. But it could have carried a much bigger payload, and it could have reached Mars faster.

Is The Focus On India's "Cheap" Mission To Mars Missing The Point?
doomgiver
doomgiver #110
Nov 26, 2014 at 5:50 PM
As i said, atm, its a pissing contest. (who can piss the furthest)

Mars mission did NOTHING other than put a basic satellite in orbit around mars. As i said before, it(mangalyaan) doesnt have any decent scientific instruments to qualify as a "science" probe.

Everytime I see someone talk about mangalyaan, they get so freaking proud that a cheap indian probe did all this. They forget this is 2013, and the first successful mars mission happened in 1970's.

We're 40 years late to the party.

Stop acting as if it makes us special.
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #111
Nov 26, 2014 at 7:14 PM
Overconfidence has ruined more people than humility.
Confidence or overconfidence,still we are proving ourselves not to some sh!tty race against advanced nations + economy + technology,but to gain knowledge and understanding. It is for this aspect,this mission though indigenious ,still got co-operation from U.S.(NASA Deep Space Network) ,AUS Deep Space Network ,EU Nations,more or less in a Global scale.

You mean to say,that since we are quite some years back,we should keep our hands folded and sit quiet returning to medieval ages....
Again Man you are comparing "Guavas" to "Apples".
But , Guava is no crap fruit and it is adored by most of the people .
Apples obviously do have its own being and presence,and is generally considered an elite and super fruit,undeniably.

After the above discussions,it is LAUGHABLE TO COMPARE INDIA WITH THE U.S. EVERYTIME.
It really makes NO SENSE AT ALL WITH THIS ILLOGICAL COMPARISON.
Anorion
Anorion #112
Nov 26, 2014 at 8:52 PM
^not at all. But with a little more effort, or actually a little less failure, ISRO could have actually done something substantial. The biggest achievement for this mission has been just getting there. That was all they aimed for also, there are no major objectives beyond that, so it feels like an empty mission, and a waste of that little money they spent also. Probably could have tested their navigation / communication / mission planning prowess in a simulator, and used the resources for an actual scientific mission.

And apples are just a fruit, not a super fruit.

Hopefully the methane sensor does something
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #113
Nov 26, 2014 at 9:02 PM
^not at all. But with a little more effort, or actually a little less failure, ISRO could have actually done something substantial. The biggest achievement for this mission has been just getting there. That was all they aimed for also, there are no major objectives beyond that, so it feels like an empty mission, and a waste of that little money they spent also. Probably could have tested their navigation / communication / mission planning prowess in a simulator, and used the resources for an actual scientific mission.

And apples are just a fruit, not a super fruit.

Hopefully the methane sensor does something
May I humbly, know, what will be our(common man) stand for this event?
abhigeek
abhigeek #114
Nov 26, 2014 at 9:13 PM
I just sitting here , waiting for ISRO Scam:lol:
beingGamer
beingGamer #115
Nov 26, 2014 at 9:35 PM
As i said, atm, its a pissing contest. (who can piss the furthest)

Mars mission did NOTHING other than put a basic satellite in orbit around mars. As i said before, it(mangalyaan) doesnt have any decent scientific instruments to qualify as a "science" probe.

Everytime I see someone talk about mangalyaan, they get so freaking proud that a cheap indian probe did all this. They forget this is 2013, and the first successful mars mission happened in 1970's.

We're 40 years late to the party.

Stop acting as if it makes us special.

You are talking like,
Hey someone climbed Mount Everest 40 years ago. Taking a first step to it in first attempt is so pussy, lets teleport to the top.
Its call reasearch & development, it will be step by step only. Its not like someone else did this, so we have to do even further without understanding how the other achieved it in the first place.
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #116
Nov 26, 2014 at 9:40 PM
You are talking like,
Hey someone climbed Mount Everest 40 years ago. Taking a first step to it in first attempt is so pussy, lets teleport to the top.
Its call reasearch & development, it will be step by step only. Its not like someone else did this, so we have to do even further without understanding how the other achieved it in the first place.

+10000..... to this.

That is a comment made by a sane,logical and common sense bearing person.
Kudos to you,Friend [MENTION=265475]anikkket[/MENTION].
Vyom
Vyom #117
Nov 27, 2014 at 12:37 AM

Is the cost of Mangalyaan - India's Mars Mission - of Rs. 450 crore, or $ 71 million justified?

Only first post is sufficient.
doomgiver
doomgiver #118
Nov 27, 2014 at 3:15 AM


i didnt say anything about going back to ancient times, lol. you made that all up. its just your imagination.

only the person who goes 1st to mount everest is remembered. nobody remembers the others. sure, today you can go and climb it, but that wont be as spectacular as the 1st time it was done, and you'll not be celebrated. do you know who Nazir Sabir is? he's the 1st paki to climb everst. who gives a flying fvck about that? now imagine if pakistanis celebrate a lot and call this guy god and say that this was the best thing ever, look how stupid it'd be.

Think for a moment and know how far behind we are. what we've done is nice, but nothing to boast about. its nothing new. dont inflate your egos.
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #119
Nov 27, 2014 at 1:43 PM
^What is your problem man?
Is this ego hurting you or others???
Just explain within the perspective.
beingGamer
beingGamer #120
Nov 27, 2014 at 3:39 PM
^What is your problem man?
Is this ego hurting you or others???
Just explain within the perspective.

seems like he can't digest this news.

Someone reached Mars so there is no point of someone else going there?

PS: get well soon [MENTION=102842]doomgiver[/MENTION]
Nerevarine
Nerevarine #121
Nov 27, 2014 at 3:45 PM

Is the cost of Mangalyaan - India's Mars Mission - of Rs. 450 crore, or $ 71 million justified?

Only first post is sufficient.
Nice post
doomgiver
doomgiver #122
Nov 27, 2014 at 8:44 PM
Is this ego hurting you or others???

are you butthurt that nobody is showering attention on your mars mission? hahaha, thats so cute!

you guys just dont get it, do you? you're making a mountain out of a molehill. im sorry i dont share your delusion of the mars mission. why dont you actually take time to see that sending a probe to mars is no big deal.

in the meantime, enjoy your imaginary success, since nobody else things its worth even noticing, LOL.
Nerevarine
Nerevarine #123
Nov 27, 2014 at 9:06 PM
Why are you so narcissist ? Sure most of your points are valid, no arguments there but there's no reason to lash out at other members ..you need to calm the hell down dude
doomgiver
doomgiver #124
Nov 27, 2014 at 9:13 PM
here's something to think about :

there's a saying that "dont reinvent the wheel", it means that dont do things that have been done before just for the sake of doing them.

^ this is what we just did. it was a pure d!<k waving contest, with zero scientific matter.

lets build our own aircraft carrier, just to show the world we can do it, even tho we dont have enough naval/airpower to use it effectively.
lets build our own space shuttle, just to show the world we can do it, even tho we dont have a space program to use it effectively.
lets build our own cricket stadium, just to show the world we can do it, even tho nobody would be allowed to use it.

same thing with the moon mission, pure pissing contest. instead of sending proper scientific probes, we're just indulging in showing off.

**** THE MANGALYAAN, cant you see it doenst benefit us??? you're the problem here, blind people falling for politician's speeches.

I'd have ZERO problems if we'd actually sent a decent probe there, but we didnt, thats the main freaking point, you gormless worms.

- - - Updated - - -

Why are you so narcissist ? Sure most of your points are valid, no arguments there but there's no reason to lash out at other members ..you need to calm the hell down dude

they started d!cking about first. and i just said they were wrong. i'll not back down from this. let the mods intervene.
snap
snap #125
Nov 27, 2014 at 9:23 PM
Always enjoy doomgiver's posts. They are pretty legit :D
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #126
Nov 27, 2014 at 11:02 PM
are you butthurt that nobody is showering attention on your mars mission? hahaha, thats so cute!

you guys just dont get it, do you? you're making a mountain out of a molehill. im sorry i dont share your delusion of the mars mission. why dont you actually take time to see that sending a probe to mars is no big deal.

in the meantime, enjoy your imaginary success, since nobody else things its worth even noticing, LOL.

Ha..Ha..Ha enjoying your lame comments dude. You are so excited at the same time confused and bewildered,that you are churning up good English language with superlative knowledge. Carry on dude...enjoying your outrage... It seems YOU ARE THE ONLY ONE WHO HAS SHOWN KEEN INTEREST in this thread section,else you wouldn't have carried too far with your unnoticeable,ignorant EGO...
So you could easily mixup between "thinks" and "things"...

Like it OR Hate it,undeniable fact is that India has made herself proud due to the Mangalyaan or MOM project.
The journey itself is a success ,which we should be proud of...enjoy it...and cherish it.

If this wretched ,good-for-nothing, country doesn't suits you,why don't you move on to U.S. or Europe????????????????????????
There you could have your endless ,sleepless days rebuking and howling against India.

The Mars Mission is India's mission not my personal mission. Till now you being a citizen(doubtful) of India,you are bound to share its success or failure...
doomgiver
doomgiver #127
Nov 28, 2014 at 12:01 AM
Till now you being a citizen(doubtful) of India,you are bound to share its success or failure...

oho, so this is nazi germany, that i HAVE to celebrate with a gun held against my head? where dissidents are publicly jailed and shot ?
GZ, and enjoy your "yindia".

and keep on imagining that the world suddenly became that much brighter and poverty was instantly banished and everyone is shooting rainbow out of their bums just because we put a chunk of metal around mars.

/slowclap

vande matram.

- - - Updated - - -

^ THATS whats wrong with you, you think EVERYONE should have YOUR opinion as their only opinion.

OMG, HE DOESNT LIKE MANGALYAAN, FVCK THIS HATER, BURRRRRRRRN.

If you'd thing rationally, you'd think otherwise.

go screw yourself, this thread has become toxic to decent conversation, better lock it down (like the rest of dissidents).

jai hind.
beingGamer
beingGamer #128
Nov 28, 2014 at 12:48 AM
[MENTION=102842]doomgiver[/MENTION] in what kind of profession are you?
I am human and i believe that to reach the top I have to take each step one at a time. It is called Research & development.
Unless you get the basic understanding from your own experience you cant take the next step.

stop whining. we are proud of what the scientists have achieved and lernt from their own experience let it be small or big or someone else have already done it. doing it by your own hands is different.
Anorion
Anorion #129
Nov 28, 2014 at 1:12 AM
:lol: try not to get personal people, and avoid swearing.
doomgiver
doomgiver #130
Nov 28, 2014 at 1:33 AM
stop whining. we are proud of what the scientists have achieved and lernt from their own experience let it be small or big or someone else have already done it. doing it by your own hands is different.

nobody is whining around here, i see only a few people who are delusional that the mars mission was actually a huge gift for humanity. thats all. sure, do it yourself, dont make drama over it. it wasnt that dramatic.
snap
snap #131
Nov 28, 2014 at 1:33 AM
meh, leave it as it is or maybe move to the fight club :D
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #132
Nov 28, 2014 at 7:14 AM
To all my @TDF, Friends including [MENTION=102842]doomgiver[/MENTION],and obviously the Mods. & Admins.
Whose comment is too personal and too toxic and too acidic?

Judge it youselves .
I am shutting up,and I don't want to join any Fight Club,because I am tooo weak for that.

Awaiting for the pics. to be released publicly , by our MOM.
abhigeek
abhigeek #133
Nov 28, 2014 at 12:46 PM
*grabs popcorn
doomgiver
doomgiver #134
Nov 28, 2014 at 5:58 PM
Haha, first you call out people, and when that tactic fails, you run away? No wonder you're too weak for the fight club.
You cant even comprehend my posts or make a coherent argument.
kg11sgbg
kg11sgbg #135
Nov 28, 2014 at 7:35 PM
Data collection and processing by various instruments ,particularly methane sensors,going in by full swing,by MOM.
W
Nov 29, 2014 at 12:40 AM
[MENTION=102842]doomgiver[/MENTION],

sending a probe to mars is no big deal

it was a pure d!<k waving contest, with zero scientific matter
I'd have ZERO problems if we'd actually sent a decent probe there, but we didnt, thats the main freaking point, you gormless worms.

just because we put a chunk of metal around mars

I didn't know that you are an expert at using differential-algebric techniques to globally optimize multi-gravity-assist interplanetary trajectories with deep space maneuvers(no it is not gibberish but real stuff,[*bt.pa.msu.edu/pub/papers/GASPDAM12/GASPDAM12.pdf). Maybe you were too tired working out these complex equations that you forgot about following some civility while posting the above lines.let me help you by giving you a short rest period of 2 days.:)

On a serious note you wouldn't believe a religious nut job decrying the latest scientific advancement in biotechnology as against god/nature because he doesn't know what he is talking about about but you seem pretty eager to dismiss this mission as nothing as if you solve space exploration level differential equations to pass your free time instead of browsing or playing sudoku.Posts like these are one of the reason that whatever correct things you also say remains ineffective to leave an impression on others.

No more off topic posts here,if someone want to comment on usefulness/difficulty level/....... of this mission get a PhD in astrophysics &/or economics & then post else stick to posting about news related to this mission(success,achievements,future missions etc).