DIGIT-ARC read-only archive · snapshot: July 23, 2026

Samsung galaxy S3 or HTC One X+?

11 posts · originally from https://geek.digit.in/community/threads/samsung-galaxy-s3-or-htc-one-x.172969/

A
ani123 Original post #1
Apr 21, 2013 at 9:29 PM
Friends,

I am looking for a powerful mobile device within 30K budget. Finally zeroed two devices, but confused to choose one among this.

I am not bothered about expandable storage and battery.

Are custom ROM's and developer support there for HTC One X+? the same like S3?

is there any other constraints which makes one device better than the other?

Please help me choosing one. If possible suggest other devices too under this budget.

Thanks in advance.
shreymittal
Apr 21, 2013 at 10:21 PM
IMO Instead of S3 and HOX+ GET XPERIA SP
SP will eat both of them alive..

Else get LG Optimus G
thetechfreak
Apr 21, 2013 at 10:52 PM
Choose either the Xperia SP or the Optimus G. Both are good phones.
quagmire
Apr 21, 2013 at 11:31 PM
Why get XSP when you can get the quad core Optimus G..? :wink:

Do consider Xperia ZL..

ani123, Just a tip: Search the Buying advice, Mobiles and Tablets threads before asking..
I am saying coz somebody else might have posted a similar query before..
V
vpower #6
Apr 21, 2013 at 11:53 PM
Obviously Optimus G is better than X-SP. But Optimus G is not within OP's budget-Flipkart price Rs.31K. Within 25 to 30K, Galaxy S3 still is a very good choice.
guru_urug
Apr 22, 2013 at 12:28 AM
Obviously Optimus G is better than X-SP. But Optimus G is not within OP's budget-Flipkart price Rs.31K. Within 25 to 30K, Galaxy S3 still is a very good choice.

The Galaxy S3 is still a good choice, maybe now. But for how much longer? Its already almost a year old now. Its hardware will not be relevant(in high end) in a few months. Will it get key lime pie? And there are Krait S4 pro's dominating the performance category right now. Considering all that, doesnt make sense to go for last year's tech. And Galaxy S3 is bad at multitasking, which personally has put me off. Flipkart and HS18 have 2k cashback offers on Optimus G, so its under 31k. Even if Optimus G is 1k more than OP's budget it is totally worth it, cause its more future proof. That 1k pales in comparison when you consider that it has a S4 pro chipset with adreno 320 GPU which is much better than the exynos 4412 and mali 400MP. And it comes with 2 GB RAM which is gonna be very beneficial when it comes to future android updates, so it will get Key Lime Pie futher more cause it is closely related to the nexus 4 and ROM development will be easier. Heck if OP doesnt mind not having warranty, he can get the Nexus 4 itself. If not these two, then OP should go for the Xperia SP, it is a damn good phone too and better than S3 anyday.

BTW if OP is ok with ebay, I found a deal offering Optimus G for 25500/-(with weekend016 coupon) which is a steal price! link below
Link
V
vpower #8
Apr 22, 2013 at 9:59 AM
The Galaxy S3 is still a good choice, maybe now. But for how much longer?
It's true!! That's exactly why I am going to buy SP which is true value at 25K.

Suggested S3 if choice is between S3 and One X+
shreymittal
Apr 22, 2013 at 10:15 AM
@vpower read the full comment first :)
Will suggest you Optimus G only. Best smart phone in that price range
quagmire
quagmire #10
Apr 22, 2013 at 7:09 PM
BTW if OP is ok with ebay, I found a deal offering Optimus G for 25500/-(with weekend016 coupon) which is a steal price! link below
Link


Nothing about warranty mentioned by seller!
guru_urug
guru_urug #11
Apr 22, 2013 at 10:42 PM
Nothing about warranty mentioned by seller!
My bad, it comes with 1 year seller warranty. Might as well go for Nexus 4 at 25k then. If 31k is not affordable for OP, he should stick with Xperia SP.