DIGIT-ARC read-only archive · snapshot: July 23, 2026

Samsung Galaxy S3 or LG Nexus 4

39 posts · originally from https://geek.digit.in/community/threads/samsung-galaxy-s3-or-lg-nexus-4.180152/

KiLL
KiLL Original post #1
Dec 21, 2013 at 6:53 PM
Im in a dillema between these two phones . I want a decent gaming performance and support for atleast a year . I have shortlisted these two devices . Please suggest me which one shld i get
ZTR
ZTR #2
Dec 21, 2013 at 6:57 PM
Nexus 4 hands down
Although the low internal memory might be a problem.
SaiyanGoku
Dec 21, 2013 at 9:15 PM
Have you considered buying nexus 5?
H
Dec 21, 2013 at 9:28 PM
Nexus 5 is the best choice. If out of budget then get Nexus 4 hands down.
Hrishi
Hrishi #5
Dec 22, 2013 at 12:32 AM
the only reason not to buy n4 would be it's onscreen overlay buttons and no external memory support. Rest is for you to decide.
ankush28
Dec 22, 2013 at 1:13 AM
the only reason not to buy n4 would be it's onscreen overlay buttons.

it may be for you...
Many of us LOVEs this ;) including me.
Capacitive and hard keys may not work properly after some time due to wear and tear.
You may be aware of samsung's service, just imagine what will happen next.
Hrishi
Hrishi #7
Dec 22, 2013 at 1:46 AM
it may be for you...
Many of us LOVEs this ;) including me.
Capacitive and hard keys may not work properly after some time due to wear and tear.
You may be aware of samsung's service, just imagine what will happen next.
are you aware that that nexus 4 feature can be used in any of the devices* ??
Akira
Akira #8
Dec 22, 2013 at 1:51 AM
Well, Nexus 4 has my vote. More value for money(faster, has Vanilla and upgradable). It has no microSD slot though(inbuilt 8-16 GB). The front camera is a bit jittery, if you really care about that.
RohanM
RohanM #9
Dec 22, 2013 at 11:38 AM
I am n N4 user since last 7 months... But my vote is for S3..

Vanilla android is bakvas.. updates lol got 3 ota in 2 weeks ... but nothing new.. only show off 4.4.2..
Battery not good as compared with S3..
And the most IMP screen .. u will love S3's amoled..
SD slot..superb cam are in favor of S3...

Yeah I knw I fought with many people in my own fanboyism for N4.. But now that's over.. (naye ke 9 din like that)
S3 also got 4.3.. do not that much behind... and trust me 4.4.2.. is nothing special...


or get a used S4...
or get a Xperia ZL or ZR....much better....
sksundram
sksundram #10
Dec 22, 2013 at 11:43 AM
Totally agree. If price is same, S3 is a winner with better battery.
$hadow
$hadow #11
Dec 22, 2013 at 12:18 PM
I would suggest you to get s3.
Hrishi
Hrishi #12
Dec 22, 2013 at 1:15 PM
Hey Guys,


You All Know that Max Payne 2 is Scheduled for release on 15th Oct. this month...
Let's share some views abt the new Max Payne 2..
Please post some topics relating to it...


Max 8)

I have optimus g at&t variant on top of which nexus 4 was built. Trust me other than camera my baby beats S3 in every aspect , the display is one of the best I have seen particularly due to One glass.

I wonder how inferior nexus 4 is.
ZTR
ZTR #13
Dec 22, 2013 at 1:34 PM
I have optimus g at&t variant on top of which nexus 4 was built. Trust me other than camera my baby beats S3 in every aspect , the display is one of the best I have seen particularly due to One glass.

I wonder how inferior nexus 4 is.

N4 has a inferior display to G just read the reviews
omega44-xt
Dec 23, 2013 at 8:24 AM
I have optimus g at&t variant on top of which nexus 4 was built. Trust me other than camera my baby beats S3 in every aspect , the display is one of the best I have seen particularly due to One glass.

I wonder how inferior nexus 4 is.
I compared N4 & that phone side by side, believe me there is not much difference....... Both cameras are same(front n rear).... Even same battery life, approx........ Only advantage of SD slot & slimmer phone

Well, Nexus 4 has my vote. More value for money(faster, has Vanilla and upgradable). It has no microSD slot though(inbuilt 8-16 GB). The front camera is a bit jittery, if you really care about that.

6 months ago, I bought N4 over S3, simply due to the 2GB RAM & faster upgrades.... Till now nothing major was there in 4.3 & 4.4
Moreover I'm missing the network video calling option.......... sometimes my father trolls me with the S2 :wah:
So, if I had to buy a phone today, I might have bought S4 Mini, because i currently carry 2 phones
RohanM
RohanM #15
Dec 23, 2013 at 9:10 AM
I compared N4 & that phone side by side, believe me there is not much difference....... Both cameras are same(front n rear).... Even same battery life, approx........ Only advantage of SD slot & slimmer phone



6 months ago, I bought N4 over S3, simply due to the 2GB RAM & faster upgrades.... Till now nothing major was there in 4.3 & 4.4
Moreover I'm missing the network video calling option.......... sometimes my father trolls me with the S2 :wah:
So, if I had to buy a phone today, I might have bought S4 Mini, because i currently carry 2 phones

LG OP G has a very vibrant screen than N4.. I compared it.
yeah if I have to buy a phone today I will go foe GS4.. I am missing GS3's Amoled badly....
Hrishi
Hrishi #16
Dec 23, 2013 at 9:55 AM
As far as it goes with the at&t optimus g , it wins over the S3 from my point of view. If someone complains about anything other than its average camera and delicateness , it would be just too much biased towards S3.

I do accept lg's poor upgrade policy but anything after 4.0 is considerably okay. Plus it has several roms being easy to port from nexus.
Just telling the truth and not being a fan boy. S3 is good but not better.
srkmish
srkmish #17
Dec 23, 2013 at 10:18 AM
I am n N4 user since last 7 months... But my vote is for S3..

Vanilla android is bakvas.. updates lol got 3 ota in 2 weeks ... but nothing new.. only show off 4.4.2..
Battery not good as compared with S3..
And the most IMP screen .. u will love S3's amoled..
SD slot..superb cam are in favor of S3...

Yeah I knw I fought with many people in my own fanboyism for N4.. But now that's over.. (naye ke 9 din like that)
S3 also got 4.3.. do not that much behind... and trust me 4.4.2.. is nothing special...


or get a used S4...
or get a Xperia ZL or ZR....much better....

Bhai you totally jumped ship? What caused the love to be lost
ankush28
ankush28 #18
Dec 23, 2013 at 10:30 AM
^^ :eek:
RohanM
RohanM #19
Dec 23, 2013 at 11:01 AM
Bhai you totally jumped ship? What caused the love to be lost

hmm hard to explain..
I was in total hype of Nexus device.. Got it after India release.. Sold My GS3 for it..
In just one week got bored of Stock Android. then not so vibrant colors of N4 started to piss me... Then avg battery life...
& for the reason I got nexus was Fast updates, but again nothing special in 4.3 & 4.4 then 4.4.2 same boring vanilla android..
Again Camera was disappointing.. (though I don't use it that much, but on occasions it feels..)

Only plus of Nexus IMO is Raw power.. which is good for gaming & multitasking, other than that one should go for skinned Android with lots of features.. (if u say that skiined android comes with bloat ware..then simply root & remove it..)

husshh .. :p
Hrishi
Hrishi #20
Dec 23, 2013 at 11:50 AM
hmm hard to explain..
I was in total hype of Nexus device.. Got it after India release.. Sold My GS3 for it..
In just one week got bored of Stock Android. then not so vibrant colors of N4 started to piss me... Then avg battery life...
& for the reason I got nexus was Fast updates, but again nothing special in 4.3 & 4.4 then 4.4.2 same boring vanilla android..
Again Camera was disappointing.. (though I don't use it that much, but on occasions it feels..)

Only plus of Nexus IMO is Raw power.. which is good for gaming & multitasking, other than that one should go for skinned Android with lots of features.. (if u say that skiined android comes with bloat ware..then simply root & remove it..)

husshh .. :p

U used custom roms , kernels , patches and various other tweaks available on xda ??
truth about nexus 4 will bi evident to you only after a while when others will stop getting update.
ask those who were stuck on 2.3 and didnt got upgrade to 4.x , while most nexus devices did. The pain to run unstable and buggy 4.x is just unbearable.
And its not for those who love Heavy UI , it's for people who love to fiddle and try different stuff on their phone due to mass availability of various stuff. Being a nexus user yourself I am sure you know about these already. Maybe your approach or liking is different. Its about personal liking too.
ZTR
ZTR #21
Dec 23, 2013 at 11:58 AM
U used custom roms , kernels , patches and various other tweaks available on xda ??
truth about nexus 4 will bi evident to you only after a while when others will stop getting update.
ask those who were stuck on 2.3 and didnt got upgrade to 4.x , while most nexus devices did. The pain to run unstable and buggy 4.x is just unbearable.
And its not for those who love Heavy UI , it's for people who love to fiddle and try different stuff on their phone due to mass availability of various stuff. Being a nexus user yourself I am sure you know about these already. Maybe your approach or liking is different. Its about personal liking too.

Its not necessary that if a phone is stuck on 2.3 official the 4.x unofficial will be laggy lol
Case in point my Galaxy S which was last updated to 2.3.6 officially is ATM running 4.4.2 like a dream.
Its not necessary that for a good dev support you need a nexus,just a phone which has good hardware and chipset whose sources have been released unlike some **coughSamsungcough**
RohanM
RohanM #22
Dec 23, 2013 at 12:02 PM
U used custom roms , kernels , patches and various other tweaks available on xda ??
truth about nexus 4 will bi evident to you only after a while when others will stop getting update.
ask those who were stuck on 2.3 and didnt got upgrade to 4.x , while most nexus devices did. The pain to run unstable and buggy 4.x is just unbearable.
And its not for those who love Heavy UI , it's for people who love to fiddle and try different stuff on their phone due to mass availability of various stuff. Being a nexus user yourself I am sure you know about these already. Maybe your approach or liking is different. Its about personal liking too.

yeah tried almost every rom available (except PSX & MIUI) on my N4 in last 7 months..
Right now using stock with Xposed framework + gravity box..

& yup My LG optimus net old is still on 2.3.4 not even 2.3.7 !! lol
but still I did not find anything special in 4.4.2 either..
Hrishi
Hrishi #23
Dec 23, 2013 at 12:05 PM
Its not necessary that if a phone is stuck on 2.3 official the 4.x unofficial will be laggy lol
Case in point my Galaxy S which was last updated to 2.3.6 officially is ATM running 4.4.2 like a dream.
Its not necessary that for a good dev support you need a nexus,just a phone which has good hardware and chipset whose sources have been released unlike some **coughSamsungcough**

Yes but its not unlikely too . For instance take that of tegra 2 devices , the first dual cores on planet. Still dying for a 4.x beta release . Yes the release is in Alpha till date. There are numerous bugs , though hats off to the devs who did so much for it.

With nexus at least you are sure that this won't happen at all.
ZTR
ZTR #24
Dec 23, 2013 at 12:12 PM
Yes but its not unlikely too . For instance take that of tegra 2 devices , the first dual cores on planet. Still dying for a 4.x beta release . Yes the release is in Alpha till date. There are numerous bugs , though hats off to the devs who did so much for it.

With nexus at least you are sure that this won't happen at all.

Yeah also nexus is for those who like to be on the bleeding edge like me :D
R
rakesh_ic #25
Dec 23, 2013 at 1:40 PM
IMO. If you arent looking to play around with your mobile so much on OS front, go for a non Nexus whichever money can buy for u at the moment. Avoid LG if you think you need the updates flowing. Avoid samsung if you think the design is pretty normal and for the build quality.

Among N4 and S3 -> S3 wins for the goodies it is tied with other than the better specs on N4. N4 for sheer raw power.
omega44-xt
Dec 24, 2013 at 9:43 AM
IMO. If you arent looking to play around with your mobile so much on OS front, go for a non Nexus whichever money can buy for u at the moment. Avoid LG if you think you need the updates flowing. Avoid samsung if you think the design is pretty normal and for the build quality.

Among N4 and S3 -> S3 wins for the goodies it is tied with other than the better specs on N4. N4 for sheer raw power.

Agreed, if you want a high performance device, then there is no competitor to N4 for its price............
S3 is an allrounder with better screen, storage & battery life than N4 but has lower performance & slower updates compared to N4....

S3 has good dev support
Even S2 has got 4.4 from devs, but I won't install it on dad's S2 because then it will lose video calling option & Samsung goodies (currently using a 4.1.2 based custom ROM)

yeah tried almost every rom available (except PSX & MIUI) on my N4 in last 7 months..
Right now using stock with Xposed framework + gravity box..

& yup My LG optimus net old is still on 2.3.4 not even 2.3.7 !! lol
but still I did not find anything special in 4.4.2 either..

I'm using crDroid ROM....... I don't like stock because of lack of customization options, so I prefer to stick with custom (still on 4.4 though, will update after getting back to college)
Xposed works fine in 4.4 it seems but there are few modules available, but more will come as days pass
swiftshashi
Dec 24, 2013 at 2:16 PM
S3 has still got no 4.3 update,atleast in India,and there are rumours that Samsung may again skip that and go to 4.4 directly.
This BS by Samsung has made me vow never to touch a Samsung again
omega44-xt
Dec 24, 2013 at 7:26 PM
S3 has got 4.3 upgrade, rolling out globally
It would get 4.4 too, it only skipped 4.2
KiLL
KiLL #29
Dec 24, 2013 at 7:54 PM
Tthank you guys. I checked the nexus 4 at a LG care and i saw thats its back is Made of GLASS!!! It can easily break .. I think ill go for the blue S3 .. another question how about Htc one x ? Is it better than s3 and plays hd games?
A
Dec 24, 2013 at 10:59 PM
Tthank you guys. I checked the nexus 4 at a LG care and i saw thats its back is Made of GLASS!!! It can easily break .. I think ill go for the blue S3 .. another question how about Htc one x ? Is it better than s3 and plays hd games?

The S3 is better than the One X. Though at this range, i think the Xperia ZR makes more sense. Water proof and dust proof, 2 GM RAM, decent battery life, expandable memory. Anyways your call.
bubusam13
bubusam13 #31
Dec 25, 2013 at 2:09 AM
Hi I was too in confusion about S3 and N4. Go for S3. Both are powerful devices but expandable Storage, and AMOLED screen are something you don't wanna miss when you are paying so much. It got removable battery.
And more importantly, vanilla android is not that great. And you have to customize it to your taste. S3 got better camera.

Yes if its between S3, S4 and N5, surely N5 then.
srkmish
srkmish #32
Dec 25, 2013 at 9:24 AM
I thought N4 wud trump S3 in suggestions here. But its clear that vanilla android is not as good as hyped up to be. Some do love the touchwiz interface. This is the great thing about android. Lots of choices and freedom.
omega44-xt
Dec 25, 2013 at 10:00 AM
Hi I was too in confusion about S3 and N4. Go for S3. Both are powerful devices but expandable Storage, and AMOLED screen are something you don't wanna miss when you are paying so much. It got removable battery.
And more importantly, vanilla android is not that great. And you have to customize it to your taste. S3 got better camera.

Yes if its between S3, S4 and N5, surely N5 then.
Between S4 & N5, the difference is performance is not as much as in case of N4 vs S3, due to 2GB vs 1GB RAM

Still between S4 & N5, N5 16GB is available for 29k, which is easily 5k less than local price of S4, but still S4 has better camera, camera features & battery life. Google has to optimize battery life in their Nexus phones
RohanM
RohanM #34
Dec 25, 2013 at 11:02 AM
If one wants S3 with 2 gigs of ram, import the I9305 ver.. this ver also don't have the Sudden death issue.
KiLL
KiLL #35
Dec 25, 2013 at 1:44 PM
Ok i chcked a import Shop here and found that the gt i905 would cost 15000 and htc one x 32gb quadcore for 12800!! So if i get those would i get warranty from Samsung or Htc .. Please tell guys final which one does make sense to go for..
RohanM
RohanM #36
Dec 25, 2013 at 3:04 PM
Ok i chcked a import Shop here and found that the gt i905 would cost 15000 and htc one x 32gb quadcore for 12800!! So if i get those would i get warranty from Samsung or Htc .. Please tell guys final which one does make sense to go for..

I9305 was not launched in India so no warranty.. But it's gr8 than regular S3 as it's having 2 gig ram.. So go for it..
swiftshashi
Dec 25, 2013 at 7:46 PM
S3 has got 4.3 upgrade, rolling out globally
It would get 4.4 too, it only skipped 4.2


But not in India yet,plus the new ROM still has battery drain,slow response issues.
omega44-xt
Dec 25, 2013 at 10:27 PM
Ok i chcked a import Shop here and found that the gt i905 would cost 15000 and htc one x 32gb quadcore for 12800!! So if i get those would i get warranty from Samsung or Htc .. Please tell guys final which one does make sense to go for..

As I9305 was never released here, so paid repairs too might be a problem......... So One X 32GB seems a better deal, but that Samsung one is too good for the price to be left off !! I would pick Samsung

Ask Samsung India about paid repairs(if accident occurs)
S
Dec 30, 2013 at 1:18 PM
Ok i chcked a import Shop here and found that the gt i905 would cost 15000 and htc one x 32gb quadcore for 12800!! So if i get those would i get warranty from Samsung or Htc .. Please tell guys final which one does make sense to go for..

So did you buy the HTC One X?