That said, I'm all ears to hear suggestions about how we might get the numbers in here...
I would suggest
1.Advertise this forum in the dgit mag, and remove the fasttrack AD about this forum. The fasttrack AD look dated and ugly which is the primary reason many think this forum is a old clunky place. Also I would suggest removing the presence of "Indian" from the ADs as it suggests that this is a place just to made to cater to Indians, a cash grab attempt to lure Indians.Try to phrase it as a feature instead of lable of this forum. Make the forum look lively and "modern", in the digit mag.
1'. While advertisements are all nice and well, they are NOTHING as compared to casually talking about the forum. If you truly like the community of this forum, put it in digit diary.
2.Also suggest people to ask advice from here in addition to agent001.
3.You should also give discussion snippets in the mag, like you did for the telegram group, it was much effective I think.
These all are the things that could have got myself in the forum, but since they obviously weren't there I got "lured in" by a mod (
@Desmond David) here, instead of getting curious about this forum from the mag itself. I speak from the perspective from a newer member instead of a veteran one.
Now about the more serious/tough changes.
I am not talking xenforo here, as I
a) Do not know enough about its customisability.
b)Think that instead of targeting xenforo specifically I should instead tell what I don't like about it, which would be more helpful.
c) Can't compare ur forums to other forums, as I don't use many.
-:
1. This is not friendly for a beginner, signing up is confusing (gmail signup already pls!). Now if you piss off a new member just on the signup screen, then, well, it would be hard to get new members won't it?
2. The UI is not there.
a)The whole UI looks dated to me, the dark mode is hard to notice and change into and it even makes many things invisible. The white theme, does NOT look pleasing.
b)In addition to that, the page looks cluttered like an RTS game, with 10s of buttons on a single page, and they won't do anything to just "blend in" in the UI, instead of popping out.
c) Why do the new button and the create button look so insignificant? I still sometimes can't find the new and create buttons, not they are not big and not colourful, but they are not in proper place.
d) There is duplication of several buttons, the top menu bar being the culprit.
3. If you can get a separate domain for this forum, please do. The geek.digit.in site has a specific purpose and UI now, and this forum doesn't look like a part of it at all. Don't trust me? Just click the "Home" button now.
Now the third aspect of the suggestion is ur revenue from this forum. Now the first thing is to take note is that its a cycle, if you make this forum good, more people would come here, which would make you improve this forum more, which would get more people and the cycle goes on.
Just make sure that this forum IS a good idea, not in 2003, but today. If you able to get sponsors on board who want to publish their ads on this forum, accept their deals. One thing I noted that, there is a lack of advertisments in this forum, like I didn't see much difference when I turned my adblocker off here. Maybe this points to a technical problem, but I would suggest you to increase the volume of (quality) ads on this forum.
In summary a)Harp about this forum b) make the UX better c) Increase the quantity of quality ads.